Five ideas looking for a better excuse
I’m trying to make a habit of noticing an irritation and imagining something that might help. These are five entries in my $100k-idea exercise. Some are useful, some are probably ridiculous. Writing them down gives me a way to find out which questions I haven’t asked yet.
These are speculative product and pricing ideas from 2012, not tested products or current offers.
PokeIt
The first idea was a disposable tool for the person tempted to pick at a blackhead or an ingrown hair with dirty fingers. I imagined a sterile, single-use device, sold in a ten-pack for $3.99. It was a product sketch, with the safety and suitability of the idea still untested.
Oh God I’m Starving, 4HB edition
This one came from being tired of the same meals. For someone following a Four Hour Body-style diet, I imagined an iPhone app showing the five nearest restaurants where they might find something to eat. Mexican restaurants would remain a fallback when nothing else appeared nearby.
The app would combine menu analysis with Yelp reviews and, where useful, OpenTable. I wanted a percentage indicating how likely the person was to find a suitable meal. Figuring out what that number could honestly mean would be part of the work. At this point, I had no business model.
Wi-Tape
Recording body measurements with an ordinary tape is a pain in the ass. Measure, write it down, type it into something else, try to make sense of the changes. I wanted a tape that could send the measurements wirelessly.
The sequence would cover each arm, the chest inflated and deflated, several points around the waist and hips, and each thigh. Combined with data from a Withings scale, it could show changes on a picture of the body. The user would choose what counted as a positive change: a smaller waist or a larger biceps, for example. Green and red would reflect that preference, rather than assume that an increase was always good or bad.
I also imagined a measurement-averaging system. It would sample readings over three seconds, discard the highest and lowest ten percent, and report the filtered value. The aim was to reduce variation from tape tension. I hadn’t tested whether that method would do it reliably.
My notes included USB and Wi-Fi, a possible partner such as Orbi-tape, and a manufacturing target below $40. A $79.99 version would measure in one-millimeter increments; a professional version would target 0.1-millimeter increments, stretch-resistant tape, and the averaging system. Those were desired specifications, not demonstrated accuracy.
I imagined manufacturing in China, building a brand, then selling the technology under other brands or licensing it to a company such as Withings. I also wrote down the possibility of patenting the averaging method. There was a fair amount of untested optimism between that note and an actual device.
Recancel
Recurring charges are easy to stop noticing. I imagined an iPhone app that would read credit-card statements and make them visible again: what the charge was, how often it appeared, and its usual amount.
It could estimate the savings from canceling and the time needed to do it. A result might say, “Save $300 by the end of the year by spending 25 minutes on the phone.” That is an example of the display I wanted, not a saving I had measured.
Where cancellation terms allowed it, the app could help cancel immediately or schedule a reminder seven days before the next billing cycle ended. My original idea went further and offered to cancel on the person’s behalf. That would need their authorization and a reliable way to carry out the request.
The pricing sketch was $4.99 for a cancellation, with analysis of the first card free and another $4.99 for the next three. I liked the possibility of making the cost of ignoring a subscription easier to see.
LazyWalker
Sometimes I’m tired, carrying something heavy, or simply don’t want to walk up another hill. LazyWalker would take a start and destination and find the route requiring the least effort.
I wanted two choices: the lowest-energy route and a suggested route that balanced effort with making reasonable progress toward the destination. Otherwise, a route that avoided every hill might become a very long walk.
The business model was the Lazy Adnetwork: all those television gadgets that make you wonder who could possibly be lazy enough to buy them. Perhaps I’d have found the audience.