The little picture that belongs to you
My children fight over their Netflix avatars. They’re still learning to read, but they know which little square belongs to whom. Choosing one also chooses the account, with its ratings and suggestions for what to watch next. My daughter tends to win these negotiations.
I’ve been watching how much those pictures matter to them while designing my reading app. An avatar could help a child recognize their own books before they can read a name. I also wonder whether it could give them some of the attachment to reading that they already bring to choosing a video.
The app is for parents and children from about six months to seven years old. That is a wide range of abilities. I want the pictures to be recognizable without requiring much explanation.
What a picture can reveal
An avatar is also a decision about what information a service asks people to share. A photograph can make a person recognizable across products. An abstract shape can distinguish one account from another while revealing less about the person behind it. Neither choice, by itself, tells me whether the service protects someone’s privacy.
For my app, I’m using curated and computer-generated avatars. I don’t allow image uploads. Reviewing every submitted image would add work I’m not equipped to take on, and an offensive image appearing in a children’s app would undermine the trust I’m trying to earn.
Messages and comments raise similar questions. A fixed set of messages limits what can be sent. Separating strangers from people a parent has approved could also limit unwanted contact, but it would still need controls that actually enforce that separation. A friendly-looking character doesn’t settle any of this.
There is a design question here too. A detailed photograph draws attention to a person’s identity. A simple shape can leave more attention on what they’ve written or done. Extra identifying detail can bring assumptions with it. For this app, a small, fairly abstract character seems like a useful place to start.
Leave room for the child
I like the freedom in Toca Boca’s Toca Tailor. It has two human characters and two animals, and the clothing choices are available to all of them. Dresses, trousers, patterns, colors: the child gets to try things out. I’m particularly fond of the sloth.
Animals and unfamiliar creatures give me another way to offer that freedom. Shape, color, and the way a character moves can make it distinctive without asking the child to choose a gender first. I want a mixture of recognizable characters and more ambiguous ones.
Watching my own children has already complicated the design. For one, changing an avatar seems to express a mood. For the other, the picture is a fairly settled identity. The child who changes pictures often also relies on where the avatar sits among the others to recognize it. I’ve considered adding a first initial so that recognition doesn’t depend entirely on the picture.
I’ve been reading about the paradox of choice, but I don’t yet know how many choices are right here. I may reduce the selection. First I want to watch how often people change their avatars and whether a few pictures account for most of the choices.
Draw a small set and see what happens
I began with two colors, one dark and one light. That constraint made me pay attention to the negative space. I hoped that a simple, slightly ambiguous character might leave more room for a child to see something of themselves in it.
I didn’t notice a large change in attachment across my two readers. Color variety mattered more to the child who liked changing avatars; it mattered less to the one who had settled on a particular character. That is a small observation, but it gives me something to follow.
The frame changes how a character appears too. A square leaves room around it. A circular crop brings attention toward the face and hides more of the surroundings. I’m interested in letting the characters appear outside those frames, on a launch screen or tucked into another part of the design. I don’t know whether that would deepen a child’s connection. It might simply be fun to spot their character somewhere unexpected.
Animation could give the picture another job. A character might smile when a child says they love a book. I’d like to release one animated avatar and see what children make of it. For this version, though, the extra animation work has to wait until after launch. Static images let me get the basic interaction into their hands sooner.
How much should they be able to change?
Nintendo’s Miis make customization appealing. You could build a character, bring it to a friend’s house, and use it when playing together. I like that continuity: a small figure carrying some sense of you into another setting.
I also found Rory Harnden’s The Face, an avatar system built into a font. It uses ligatures to assemble simple elements into increasingly expressive faces. It made me think about how much variation a small set of parts could offer.
That would take more time than I have for the first release. I’ve drawn about eighteen avatars in Sketch 3: animals, creatures, doodles, and simplified familiar characters. Three below are based on the ones Netflix provides. I may add others over time, perhaps seasonally.
For now, I want to see which ones the children choose, which they keep, and which they argue over. I can make the pictures. They’ll decide what the pictures mean to them.
